Page: [1] 2
Posted: Jan 14, 2008 7:48 am
# 1
I uploaded a few of WIP stories that I've been working on. I saw that a few people clicked on my stories but I had no reviews. It can mean two things I guess: My stories aren't good or people don't feel like reviewing.
What if there was a rating system where the readers could just rate (in one click) the story on a scale of 1 to 5 or 1 to 10? It could give the writers an idea whether their stories are good or bad when people dont want to write a review.
Just a suggestion.
Thanks.
Dont take life too seriously, you're gonna die anyway... ![[smiley]](http://www.paperdemon.com/images/forum/mysmilies/15pxyellow_wacko.gif)
Posted: Jan 14, 2008 8:48 am
# 2
I don't think a rating system for anything would be a good idea. You know the story is good by how many favs and comments you get. I think it's best we leave it at that.
Last edited by Nekoyoujo on Jan 15, 2008 8:15 am. Total edits: 1.
I left. Communty's too small. I might return when this place is bigger. Go to my other sites.
Posted: Jan 14, 2008 9:55 am
# 3
I disagree. Many people wont bother with reviews even if the story is good.
Dont take life too seriously, you're gonna die anyway...
Posted: Jan 14, 2008 1:25 pm
# 4
Profile • Send Private Msg • Artwork • Writing • Email • Website • AIM • Y!IM
Posts: 583
If I didn't leave a review... you probably wouldn't like my rating either. Sounds harsh, but it's true.
Guano smells like a dirty sock full of old cheese and farts! - Gonard
Posted: Jan 14, 2008 1:33 pm
# 5
LOL, but I would want the truth. A bad review or a bad rating is at least an idea about the story.
By the way, were you talking about my stories or figuratively?
Dont take life too seriously, you're gonna die anyway...
Posted: Jan 14, 2008 1:58 pm
# 6
I agree with Sivler. If they didn't take the time out to review ,then why would they vote. It is wasn't good enough to make them want to review ,then why rate at all? Plus no one may have even read the stry (yet) to start with.
Last edited by Nekoyoujo on Jan 15, 2008 8:15 am. Total edits: 1.
I left. Communty's too small. I might return when this place is bigger. Go to my other sites.
Posted: Jan 14, 2008 2:48 pm
# 7
Profile • Send Private Msg • Artwork • Writing • Comics • Email • Website • AIM • MSNM • GTalk
Posts: 2865
Reasons for me not commenting on the story are-
Those are my reasons, but I haven't had time to read stories. Currently, I read/comment on storys if asked. I'm *really* busy. But yeah- if that's any insight.
![[smiley]](http://www.paperdemon.com/images/forum/mysmilies/15pxyellow_pdwings.gif)
Show your Paper Demon love! Hug a submission and tell it why you love it so much ^^
Posted: Jan 14, 2008 4:57 pm
# 8
Profile • Send Private Msg • Artwork • Writing • Comics • Email • AIM
Posts: 768
Actually I agree with Lili. Alot of the time when I read a story and I almost never comment. That doesn't mean I didn't like it most of the time I do like the story. I just get lazy and opt out of not commenting to tell the truth. ![[smiley]](http://www.paperdemon.com/images/forum/mysmilies/15pxyellow_sweatdrop.gif)
A ratng system would be really smart. If the reader didn't like it I'd wanna know even if they didn't comment or anything. It gives the writer an idea that they should up their writing or keep doing what they're doing. Over at sheezy there's a rating system and I usually rate the pic before even commenting or faving. Sometimes that's all I do. Rate it and go. It's a bad thing to admit but that's the truth. People just don't want to comment most of the time. They'll look and fave or do nothing and go. I back up the rating system ![[smiley]](http://www.paperdemon.com/images/forum/mysmilies/15pxyellow_yes.gif)
Last edited by Jilly on Jan 14, 2008 4:57 pm. Total edits: 1.
Friendship is like peeing on yourself: everyone can see it, but only you get the warm feeling that it brings.
Posted: Jan 14, 2008 7:26 pm
# 9
If you like it so much then fav and go. Rating wouldn't help anything...that BEARLY even helps an ego. On that note, I think rating would do something to/with egos. It's enough to see someone with favs and comments...and ratings too. Come on. Let's keep it at an equal enough level.
If you rate stories ,they run that into the art. I REALLY don't wanna see that on my art. If you want ratings Sheezy does that. I don't wanna see this site become Sheezy. *hides in fear*
Last edited by Nekoyoujo on Jan 15, 2008 8:15 am. Total edits: 3.
I left. Communty's too small. I might return when this place is bigger. Go to my other sites.
Posted: Jan 14, 2008 8:23 pm
# 10
Profile • Send Private Msg • Artwork • Writing • Comics • Email • Website • AIM • MSNM • GTalk
Posts: 2865
I agree with Neko- ratings are biase and can change depending on the subject- not the QUALITY. I will always leave a comment if I have something to say, but people are sometimes lazy- it's life.
Show your Paper Demon love! Hug a submission and tell it why you love it so much ^^
Posted: Jan 14, 2008 8:37 pm
# 11
Profile • Send Private Msg • Artwork • Writing • Website • ICQ • AIM • Y!IM • MSNM • GTalk
Posts: 3742
There have been suggestions for rating systems like this in the past many times. Every time it's been suggested the majority of those who voice their opinions tend to be against a rating system. Mostly because people are afraid that PD will become like DA and a couple other communities and just be nothing but a popularity contest. This is why favorites are private on entries.
However, I would not be against a rating system if the ratings were only visible to the author/artist who posted the submission. What do you guys think of something like that?
Last edited by BogusRed on Jan 14, 2008 8:38 pm. Total edits: 1.
Please help support PaperDemon. Grow our community or purchase a premium account.
Posted: Jan 14, 2008 8:41 pm
# 12
Profile • Send Private Msg • Artwork • Writing • Comics • Email • AIM
Posts: 768
On Jan 14, 2008 8:37 pm, BogusRed said:
However, I would not be against a rating system if the ratings were only visible to the author/artist who posted the submission. What do you guys think of something like that?
I was just about to mention something like that. Like have the ratings private where only the artist or author can see what the ratings are or have an option where they can turn off ratings on a certain submission in case they don't want to see them at all. I'd be all for that
Friendship is like peeing on yourself: everyone can see it, but only you get the warm feeling that it brings.
Posted: Jan 14, 2008 9:15 pm
# 13
I am all for the author/artist-viewed-only rating system. At first I wasn't sure why people are mostly all against a rating system which seems like a great idea- but now I can imagine seeing all the popularity artist with popular fanworks getting top ratings despite quality.
Posted: Jan 15, 2008 5:05 am
# 14
I think that people who usually review wouldn't stop reviewing because there is also a rating system. But for those who are not into writing review could just , by a click, say if they liked it or not.
Also, I get the feeling that people are forgetting what reviewing mean. Silverbane and Nekoyoujo, Off course I would want the rating/review even if it's bad. Reviewing doesn't mean only saying nice things. It's also having the honesty to say what you really think. What can be improve and what not to do.
No review can mean so many thing, when the review or rating is bad then at least you know.
Yes BR, I think your idea is good!
Dont take life too seriously, you're gonna die anyway...
Posted: Jan 15, 2008 8:13 am
# 15
B.R. - It's still not a good iodea. The fact that there IS a rating system would still make it biase.
Lilimay - It's not about negative or positive reviews. If you got a review that should be enough. Ratings arent needed. It sounds like another reason to attention whore, like on dA/ Sheezy.
Last edited by Nekoyoujo on Jan 15, 2008 8:16 am. Total edits: 1.
I left. Communty's too small. I might return when this place is bigger. Go to my other sites.
Posted: Jan 15, 2008 8:33 am
# 16
I'll repeat myself. Many people just don't write reviews. The story might be good but they wont review, because let's be honest; not all people like to review.
Explain the difference between a review and a rating?
How would a simple rating of 1 to 5 for the people who don't like to review, give another reason for attention whore as you put it?
I feel like you disregard the many people who don't care about reviewing. Im not saying that all the non-reviewers will start rating, but some who just don't feel like reviewing will at least give the author an idea about their story.
No review...can mean too many thing. A rating, gives an idea. I want to give the people who dont like to review a chance of voicing their opinion, not because I want to bask in the glory of a waterfall of nice words. I cant understand your arguments about ego and attention whores...I feel like it's irrelevent to the debate.No offence.
Last edited by Lilimayhem on Jan 15, 2008 8:35 am. Total edits: 1.
Dont take life too seriously, you're gonna die anyway...
Posted: Jan 15, 2008 8:50 am
# 17
I don't like rating systems at all. I have been on other sites where they use them, and trust me on this, it prmotes more laziness as people are more likely to click on a button than to leave any really useful commentary, so in the end, you get less comments on all your work. So people give you a 5 out of a possible 10 on the rating system, does this really help you improve at all? Does it tell you where you fall short of hitting the mark, or where you really were skillful with your writing abilities. It is basically meaningless, especially if you take into account that some fanbases will give high marks to anything that has their favorite couple together in fanfics.
Posted: Jan 15, 2008 9:00 am
# 18
THANK YOU!
LOL, the first good argument. I see your point.
Dont take life too seriously, you're gonna die anyway...
Posted: Jan 15, 2008 12:37 pm
# 19
Now that someone's told you the difference how do you feel about it?
I left. Communty's too small. I might return when this place is bigger. Go to my other sites.
Posted: Jan 15, 2008 1:41 pm
# 20
I now see your point and understand why a rating system would be a bad idea. I can be reasoned given good arguments. lol, dies it show I like debates! ![[smiley]](http://www.paperdemon.com/images/forum/mysmilies/15pxyellow_smile.gif)
Dont take life too seriously, you're gonna die anyway...
|
|
Online: 2 members, 37 guests
After Pain is Love
Old poem I found and finished up. Can't really explain it, it is on hwo love can be found...
The Words Unsaid
One night around the campfire
PaperDemon.com
Login
