I think i like your take on them. They look very comic bookish. Honestly, it bugs me sometimes when people take and make bishie men too pretty. Beautiful work.
I never really got the impression that Sephiroth was the kind of guy that should look like a bishie. I thought he was tall and strong, not some wimpy stick-like character.
Unfortunately, not too many artists seem to agree with me about that.
I agree completely. Unfortunately a lot of people think he needs to be this wispy effeminate man-boi that looks like he should be going out with Adam Lambert LMAO. I included my take on the One winged angel xD
I think he looks less like a bishie in Advent Children. There were still some animeish features, but at least he actually had some bulk there.